For many managers of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), accounting is often seen as an administrative burden, a formality required to meet annual tax obligations or the demands of banking institutions.
And yet, behind the figures and analysis tables lies an essential steering tool for the company throughout the financial year. Indeed, when financial statements are poorly prepared or contain recurring errors, they can give a distorted view of the company’s economic reality. The result of strategic decisions taken on the basis of inaccurate information can sometimes have consequences for the company’s profitability, cash flow or even business continuity.
Even when accounts are drawn up according to the rules, certain errors are systematically recurring in SME accounting. These inaccuracies, often unintentional, can have an impact on day-to-day management as well as short, medium and long-term planning, depending on the projects required to ensure the company’s survival and growth.
1- Improperly treated immobilizations
One of the most common errors concerns the way in which major expenditures are recorded. For example, the purchase of new equipment, software or a vehicle should generally be recorded as an asset (and depreciated over several years), as it provides a lasting economic benefit. However, some companies write these costs off directly as expenses, artificially reducing their profit for the year. Conversely, current expenses such as repairs and operating costs are sometimes wrongly capitalized, inflating assets without justification.
Another common error concerns the depreciation of fixed assets. In principle, a fixed asset should be depreciated to reflect its loss of value over time. In many small and medium-sized businesses, however, depreciation is often calculated on an approximate basis: depreciation periods are sometimes chosen arbitrarily, rarely revised over the years, and applied uniformly to very different assets.
For example, computer equipment may be depreciated over ten years, whereas its actual useful life rarely exceeds four years. In such a context, the financial statements run the risk of presenting assets that still appear to have significant value on paper, when in practice their economic value is already greatly diminished, or even non-existent.
Another common situation is to keep assets on the balance sheet that are no longer actually used in the company’s operations. Examples include equipment that has been replaced, software that is no longer used, obsolete equipment and vehicles that are no longer in service.
In many SMEs, these items remain on the books simply because they have been capitalized in the past, and no subsequent review has been carried out to determine whether they should be written off or presented separately in the financial statements. However, when these fixed assets remain on the books, the note to the financial statements showing cost and accumulated depreciation can also be distorted. This gives a misleading picture of assets still in use by the company.
2- Recognize income at the right time: avoid accounting illusions
It’s tempting to recognize income as soon as a payment is received, even if the service or product has not yet been delivered. For example, a deposit paid by a customer for a future order should not be recorded as immediate income, but as a liability (“deferred income”) until the company has fulfilled its obligations.
Another tricky point concerns the tracking of work-in-progress according to its stage of completion. Work in progress represents projects or assets under construction that have not yet been completed, but for which costs have already been incurred.
According to the Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE), it is essential to determine the percentage of completion of work to correctly calculate the amount to be treated as a current realizable asset and, where appropriate, the income to be recognized. In practice, this is not always done accurately. When the degree of completion is incorrectly assessed, income may be recognized too quickly or, on the contrary, deferred unnecessarily. In such cases, recognizing revenue too quickly can artificially inflate a year’s profits, conceal future commitments and distort cash flow forecasts.
3- How to classify debts: short-term or long-term?
Distinguishing between debts to be repaid within the year (short-term) and those of a longer-term nature is crucial in assessing a company’s liquidity. For example, part of a loan may fall due within the next 12 months. If this due date is not correctly identified, financial indicators (such as working capital) may be inaccurate, which may worry financial partners.
Misclassification of debts can give a false impression of financial solidity or, on the contrary, fragility, and wrongly influence the decisions of banks or partners.
4- Shareholder advances: costly vagueness
In SMEs, financial exchanges between the company and its shareholders are often numerous and sometimes poorly documented. A cash withdrawal may be considered a loan, an expense reimbursement, a dividend or simply a personal withdrawal. Without clear internal traceability by the accounting team, these amounts risk being misclassified in the accounts, which can distort the company’s financial structure.
Misclassification can complicate relations with banks, associates or even government and tax authorities.
Why do these mistakes matter so much?
All in all, the errors mentioned above are not necessarily fraudulent. They often stem from a misunderstanding of accounting rules.
All these inaccuracies have one thing in common: they distort the company’s economic reality. Inaccurate financial statements can :
- Give the impression that the company is more profitable or stronger than it really is (or vice versa).
- Make it harder to obtain financing or negotiate with financial partners.
- Lead to ill-adapted strategic decisions, such as overly risky investments or excessive pressure on working capital.
The key role of the CPA: more than just an auditor
Our team is here to support you, advise you and help you make informed decisions. Well-kept accounts are not just a legal requirement: they are essential steering tools for understanding performance, establishing a solid foundation, anticipating difficulties and seizing opportunities for growth. The professionals at Amyot Gélinas can paint a clear picture of your company’s performance. In addition to objectively verifying your financial information, they also make sure they understand the business implications that flow from these results. In addition, our professionals will assist and guide you in the production and presentation of financial information. This way, you can be sure of meeting all regulatory requirements.
An article by Nicolas Barrette-Des-Lauriers, CPA auditor
For further reading :
